ARCHIVED FORUM -- March 2012 to February 2022READ ONLY FORUM
This is the second Archived Forum which was active between 1st March 2012 and 23rd February 2022
I use Roon myself, but not direct on B&O speakers.
B&O speakers have no Roon endpoint build in right now (which is real shame ;-)
I use a streamer in between.
Another option is to use airplay of chromecast (not airplay2) to directly connect to B&O speakers.
steve1977:I’m a bit less clear how it actually works alongside of b&o products
1. Chromecast
2. Airplay
3. A Roon ready/compatible device or Mac/PC connected to B&o
steve1977:what gets people excited about it?
steve1977:It seems fairly pricey for what it does?
steve1977:so the b&o app cannot access the roon server over dlna
steve1977:How does the roon multi-room work and does it work with b&o speakers?
Something to read and check out:
https://land.roonlabs.com/introducing-1-8?utm_source=email_blast&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=1_8_software_launch&utm_content=e
https://roonlabs.com/?utm_source=campaign_land_page&utm_medium=campaign_land_page&utm_campaign=1_8_software_launch
And I really have to say that Roon's own RAAT protocol appeals to me much more than chromecast or even airplay. RAAT via a Roon ready device just sounds much better ... try it out!
Even my BS2, which now runs via RAAT instead of Chromecast, gives me more pleasure now in terms of sound.
What is also outstanding, where else can you find that?, I can listen to all my CDs in a library together with the albums / tracks streamed from streaming services, create playlists ... for me this simply is great :)
.
Present: BL90, Core, BL6000, CD7000, Beogram 7000, Essence Remote.
Past: BL1, BL2, BL8000, BS9000, BL5, BC2, BS5, BV5, BV4-50, Beosystem 3, BL3, DVD1, Beoremote 4, Moment.
steve1977:I’m a bit less clear how it actually works alongside of b&o products and what gets people excited about it? It seems fairly pricey for what it does?
https://roonlabs.com/features
The big Roon 1.8 update next week is supposed to be much nicer for classical music from I read.
Might be of interest to you good self
(feel free of course to disregard my musings!)
seethroughyou:No Deezer but otherwise great.
One final parting shot.....
For those who stream casually from their hone using a streaming service to the odd Beosound / Play speaker here and there, I would say Roon is far from essential.
Now that I have a set of 50s, bought primarily to get more out of music than my previous 18s, and to spend more time listening to music, Roon was essential for me and has been superb for discovery and rediscovery. I have inserted a pretty decent (Roon Ready) streamer / DAC to feed the 90s, as an optional extra. My Roon server (the Roon Nucleus) could have fed the 50s w/o the need foe the streamer / DAC, but then that's just me.
So Roon can be used a simple or more involved setups.
After while it comes with a cost, its not as if the Moment was cheap - and that was not a great experience being just a limited jukebox.
So, if you're frustrated at your music experience using the services native apps or the B&O app, I'd investigate Roon.
If you're not, then I'd carry on as before.
steve1977:It seems many of b&o fans are using roon. I’m a bit less clear how it actually works alongside of b&o products and what gets people excited about it? It seems fairly pricey for what it does? It’s a proprietary protocol, so the b&o app cannot access the roon server over dlna? How does the roon multi-room work and does it work with b&o speakers?
I’m a bit less clear how it actually works alongside of b&o products and what gets people excited about it?
It seems fairly pricey for what it does?
It’s a proprietary protocol, so the b&o app cannot access the roon server over dlna?
How does the roon multi-room work and does it work with b&o speakers?
Sandyb:So, if you're frustrated at your music experience using the services native apps or the B&O app, I'd investigate Roon.
BS Moment, BS Core, BG 4002, BC 4500, BS1, BL18, BL19, BL8000 + RCV1, A6, M5, M3, A1, P6 (tks Botty), H5, TR1
Another fan of Plex here
B&O products are V1-32, BS2, H95, E8 and an Essence remote.11-46 now replaced with Sony A90J 65”, Sony HT-A9, Sony UBP-X800M2 and Sony SRS-NS7.
mbolo01: Sandyb: of course yes - I've heard good things about using Plex and Plexamp both. Its been a while since I played with Plex - it doesn't need to run on a computer or something somewhere no? While that is true of Roon too, Roon do sell the Nucleus, which is a headless unit which maintains an updates itself pretty much. So, if you're frustrated at your music experience using the services native apps or the B&O app, I'd investigate Roon. Or look at other alternative such Plex which also brings what the Moment was intended to provide and much much more. Plexamp became my main music source to dig my 59k tracks library and expose it with unlimited angles
Sandyb: of course yes - I've heard good things about using Plex and Plexamp both. Its been a while since I played with Plex - it doesn't need to run on a computer or something somewhere no? While that is true of Roon too, Roon do sell the Nucleus, which is a headless unit which maintains an updates itself pretty much. So, if you're frustrated at your music experience using the services native apps or the B&O app, I'd investigate Roon.
of course yes - I've heard good things about using Plex and Plexamp both.
Its been a while since I played with Plex - it doesn't need to run on a computer or something somewhere no?
While that is true of Roon too, Roon do sell the Nucleus, which is a headless unit which maintains an updates itself pretty much.
Or look at other alternative such Plex which also brings what the Moment was intended to provide and much much more. Plexamp became my main music source to dig my 59k tracks library and expose it with unlimited angles
Sandyb:Its been a while since I played with Plex - it doesn't need to run on a computer or something somewhere no?
Actually it's $700 (699). But don't just close your eyes and pay, rent it for a year ($120) first. If you really really really like it, then it cost you $820 for the lifetime lease instead of 700, big deal. If you're buying B&O, even used, $120 gets you... what? A fresh Kvadrat cover for your A6?
The only reason I didn't spring for the so-called "lifetime" subscription when they were $500 a couple years back, was that even if you only use your local library, the entire system won't start up if it has been more than a month without an internet connection to their servers. That AllMusic data comes with a license to Roon, so even if the data you have downloaded is unchanged, you don't get to keep it on your own Roon server forever. They claimed that if they were to go out of business, they would throw a switch to allow use of all the technical & play features without the music magazine & MOTS features, on your local library. I didn't believe them. Of course they have stayed in business for more than 4 years (at that price) so it's moot. Nevertheless I like my ancient iTunes Mac, that just sits there and works.
If you're still on the fence, have a look at the Darko.audio video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dva4LOr7Fnk) where he hooks up a 27" touch screen to a Windows computer to use Roon. He's a technical lightweight, but his demo is fun.
steve1977:I wouldn’t want to use a roon ready device to connect beolab/beosound as i’m “allergic” to more cables... If i read this threat right, i could use the roon app though to stream to b&o via airplay-2 (multi-room) or via dlna (which i can then distribute to other speakers via b&o app or the halo).
Audirvana is a real good alternative to Roon.
+It has the same audio quality
+It is really easy to UPnP/DLNA stream to one B&o device and
+use B&o own multiroom to extend your music
+it also intergrates Tidal/Qobus
+it is much, much cheaper
+Tag info on BS35/Halo/B&o apps
-for Audirvana: the artist/album/track/genre information provided in Roon is extraordenary, but it comes with a price.
Ulrike:Even my BS2, which now runs via RAAT instead of Chromecast, gives me more pleasure now in terms of sound.
I searched on Roon's site but I can't find a partnership? Please elaborate.
BeoFrederic:Careful - I don’t believe that Roon supports Airplay 2, just original AP. Open question as to whether your use case requires AP2....
But: If you run Roon *on a Mac*, it supports AirPlay2 because you can tell it to send its sound to "System Output" rather than directly to a particular speaker, then use the MacOS to select AirPlay2 speaker(s). Personally, unless you have lots of Wi-Fi dropouts or too many speakers thus want the new AirPlay2 features, I'd stick to Roon direct without MacOS System Sound, unless multi-zone sync gets messed up. Also as of now, MacOS System Sound Output doesn't support AirPlay2 stereo pairs, but you don't need to wait for Apple to fix MacOS for that, because with Roon's built-in DSP, you can play to two AirPlay(1) zones in sync, but one of them has the trivial DSP of zero volume in the left channel and the other has zero volume in the right! (There may be some latency issues with this hack, because the sync has to be absolutely perfect for left/right, versus multi-room where "very close" is good enough.)
from memory I believe Ulrike has something Roon ready plugged into the BS2, hence turning it into a RAAT endpoint.
Carolpa: Ulrike:Even my BS2, which now runs via RAAT instead of Chromecast, gives me more pleasure now in terms of sound.\Since when does B&o supports RAAT? Interesting! I searched on Roon's site but I can't find a partnership? Please elaborate.
steve1977:Re plex - i’m a heavy plex user for over a decade, but it just doesn’t cut it for me for local music. It’s not priority for the developer and local music support is buggy. It doesn’t pick up local artist art. Picking up album art from embedded cover is flakey at best. There are numerous threats on their forum for years, but no fix at sight. Video in plex on the other hand is outstanding and cannot think of anything better.
Hello all,
I have been using Roon for about half a year and I am in love with it. I am not going to explain how it works and which technologies are used because it was covered from my fellow B&O lovers above.
For me if someone OWNS a fair amount of music Roon totally worth the money. You can always use the trial period which is enough to make you wonder why you haven't been using roon till now. If you see yourself more like a music collector (interested in artist bios, album reviews, getting to know the composers and their work and this kind of metadata) rather than the person who likes to listen to music then Roon is a great solution if not the greatest (at least for the time being). Furthermore someone can argue that the Roon Radio function (given that you spent some time to give some feedback to the system) is a solution similar to the pattern play of the beosound moment or the mots of the beosound 5. Myself I am using the Roon Radio function whenever I have people coming to my house and I have had a good amount of compliments about "MY" playlists (which were created on the fly from Roon Radio).
All in all I suggest that if you have like collecting music you should at least try it. The price is not cheap if you consider the specs of a roon server pc/mac. I started using a NAS and now I am running the roon server on a NUC (i5 6th generation with 8GB Ram) and it works like a charm.
Last but by no means least, it would be a very welcome addition to the B&O portfolio of products to be Roon ready. Many of their competitors are and I have found myself many times checking their Roon ready products. Especially for products like the 90s and the 50s it would be awesome to be able to directly stream Roon to them given the audio HD capabilities of Roon and the B&O speakers.
why not try the 14 day trial?
given you dont plan to combine local with streaming service content, Roon may be overkill for you (just my impression)
Regarding your final main paragraph : Roon will stream content (whether its local or Tidal/Qobuz) to stream to / control streams to Airplay or CC enabled B&O speakers (or any Roon ready speaker / endpoints you have).
As written elsewhere, for multiroom purposes, Roon can group Airplay speakers, and CC speakers, and Roon ready endpoints. There is no need to use the B&O app to redistribute anything. As for exposing the album covers - if I use Roon to play music on my A9 and BS2, I can't see any artwork in the B&O app, but as I'm using Roon apps for everything, it's not relevant. I'm not quite sure what your aim is here.
Sounds like you just want a good DLNA front end for your local music (correct me if I;m wrong), and I suspect Roon is overkill. Roon does give you some granular control over which artwork to use / prefer, but I'm not especially concerned with all that. The overall experience is what I pay for from Roon, whether for a few albums I'd prefer different artwork is of little importance.
Audirvana seems to get a very good press, though I have no experience myself.
steve1977:Thanks for all your helpful replies. Confirms that roon may be a great solution to pursue. Re plex - i’m a heavy plex user for over a decade, but it just doesn’t cut it for me for local music. It’s not priority for the developer and local music support is buggy. It doesn’t pick up local artist art. Picking up album art from embedded cover is flakey at best. There are numerous threats on their forum for years, but no fix at sight. Video in plex on the other hand is outstanding and cannot think of anything better. So, i’m basically looking for a “plex for music”. I hoped the moment could be it, but i don’t think i hage to say more... Was also looking for a good dlna solution, but couldn’t find a good server solution and more importantly there is not a single dlna client that meets my UI expectations. I’m looking for same UI quality like plex or plexamp. And there is just nothing. Which brought me to roon. I’m indeed a bit annoyed that it costs usd 600 for lifetime (plex’ 100-ish are more reasonable). but maybe that’s what it takes and i should give it a go? I wouldn’t want to use a roon ready device to connect beolab/beosound as i’m “allergic” to more cables... If i read this threat right, i could use the roon app though to stream to b&o via airplay-2 (multi-room) or via dlna (which i can then distribute to other speakers via b&o app or the halo). So, this could be a use case. When using dlna, i’d even get the album covers on b&o devices. So, the roon could be the client/server to stream via dlna or ap2 to b&o devices. I don’t play to combine with streaming services, so would limit to local music. Given the usd 600 price tag, could you think of any other solution providing same / similar service? Or just close my eyes and pay it? ;)
Re plex - i’m a heavy plex user for over a decade, but it just doesn’t cut it for me for local music. It’s not priority for the developer and local music support is buggy. It doesn’t pick up local artist art. Picking up album art from embedded cover is flakey at best. There are numerous threats on their forum for years, but no fix at sight. Video in plex on the other hand is outstanding and cannot think of anything better.
So, i’m basically looking for a “plex for music”. I hoped the moment could be it, but i don’t think i hage to say more... Was also looking for a good dlna solution, but couldn’t find a good server solution and more importantly there is not a single dlna client that meets my UI expectations. I’m looking for same UI quality like plex or plexamp. And there is just nothing.
Which brought me to roon. I’m indeed a bit annoyed that it costs usd 600 for lifetime (plex’ 100-ish are more reasonable). but maybe that’s what it takes and i should give it a go?
I wouldn’t want to use a roon ready device to connect beolab/beosound as i’m “allergic” to more cables... If i read this threat right, i could use the roon app though to stream to b&o via airplay-2 (multi-room) or via dlna (which i can then distribute to other speakers via b&o app or the halo). So, this could be a use case. When using dlna, i’d even get the album covers on b&o devices. So, the roon could be the client/server to stream via dlna or ap2 to b&o devices.
I don’t play to combine with streaming services, so would limit to local music.
Given the usd 600 price tag, could you think of any other solution providing same / similar service? Or just close my eyes and pay it? ;)
Funny thing Roon, all over British fora, virtually not heard of outside the UK.
I don't know anybody who has heard of it, let alone used it.
Jacques
First ...
I never use airplay because of the sound quality.https://help.roonlabs.com/portal/en/kb/articles/airplay-setup
Next ...
You can just use roon bridge for any device: https://help.roonlabs.com/portal/en/kb/articles/roonbridge I wrote something about it here: https://archivedforum2.beoworld.org/forums/p/45567/329400.aspx#329400 Soundwise it's much better now. For serious listening I prefer RAAT. https://help.roonlabs.com/portal/en/kb/articles/raat
I don't own a nucleus. I have set up an Intel NUC 8i7 BEH for Roon server, which works like a charm running Rock OS.
chartz:Funny thing Roon, all over British fora, virtually not heard of outside the UK. I don't know anybody who has heard of it, let alone used it. Jacques
Hi,
i'm using emby. its free and its not only for music. it supports dlna + chromecast and has its own app on every platform (AppleTV, GoogleTV, Android, iOS...).
It looks very nice...
BS9000 + BS Core + Beosystem 3 + BL8000 + BL4 + BL2 + BL7-1 // BeoVision 7 32“ + BL8000 // Beoplay M5 // Beoplay S3 // 2x BL3500 // 2x BeoPlay A6 + 2x Essence Remote // 2x BeoSound 8 // Playmaker + BL6000
[
Ulrike:You can just use roon bridge for any device: https://help.roonlabs.com/portal/en/kb/articles/roonbridge
I am using Aurdirvana for years now. Running on a Mac Mini that I remotely manage from my ipad/iphone with the Audirvana app and also my Beo4 to Play/Stop/change tracks
I tested Roon last year and didn't see what improvement it brings over Audirvana, for my usage, neither on the sound side (Audirvana is probably even one step forward) than on the user interface, to read my local files like accessing the streaming services. So I stick to Audirvana for which the (quite cheap) license is paid for years without having to pay a regular and expensive subscription
Carolpa: [ Ulrike:You can just use roon bridge for any device: https://help.roonlabs.com/portal/en/kb/articles/roonbridgeInteresting. But do you technical speaking enjoying RAAT or is RAAT converted to a stream accepted by B&o? I would say the latter.
RAAT (Roon Advanced Audio Transport) is Roon's own streaming protocol, which enables you to play Roon music to any Roon Ready hardware device or to devices connected to a Roon Bridge. Roon Bridge is a software package that extends Roon's audio playback capabilities i.e. RAAT to other devices or computers, including embedded platforms like the Raspberry Pi. The latter I have done (could have used a one-box solution like a bluesound node as well), thus the BS2 connected to the Roon Bridge is capable of playing RAAT.
Why dont you do the free trial of Roon and see how well it works for you?
As for multi room - if you use Roon to Airplay to a BS1, you can add another Airplay B&O speaker either in Roon (by grouping them together), or you can use the B&O app to get the second speaker to join the airplay stream that the first is enjoying. I haven't tried physically doing the Touch to Join on the second speaker, but assuming that if the B&O app can get the second speaker to join, then physical Touch to Join will also work.
When you Airplay to a B&O speaker ( I do it from Roon to my BS2 and A9), there is no album art in the B&O app. But as I'm using Roon apps, I dont care if the B&O app shows album art or not.
You get the most out of Roon if you use it for controlling / managing your music - there is no need to jump between the Roon app and the B&O app.
But again, just try out the free trial - everyone has their own specific details they care more or less about, and you're in the best position to see that when you play with it yourself in your own setup.
Its been everthing I wanted in my use case - i.e. getting away from B&O control apps for my local music, and streaming service apps for their music. Its been a joy for discovery (new stuff on Qobuz) and rediscovery of my own local collection. But if you dont use Tidal / Qobuz, then you're paying the same fee to Roon for less utility or value added.
steve1977:Did some more research. Roon indeed seems have quite some magic and may be exactly what i’m looking for as i’m definitely a “collector”. One clarification: does it really support multi-room via airplay-1? So, i can play to my BS1 and then add my Beolit 12? There seems to be some major shortcomings though (besides the price): * B&O “touch to join” won’t work * Tags not visible at Halo Both seem fine with audirvana?
Roon indeed seems have quite some magic and may be exactly what i’m looking for as i’m definitely a “collector”.
One clarification: does it really support multi-room via airplay-1? So, i can play to my BS1 and then add my Beolit 12?
There seems to be some major shortcomings though (besides the price):
* B&O “touch to join” won’t work
* Tags not visible at Halo
Both seem fine with audirvana?
Ulrike: Carolpa:[ Ulrike:You can just use roon bridge for any device: https://help.roonlabs.com/portal/en/kb/articles/roonbridgeInteresting. But do you technical speaking enjoying RAAT or is RAAT converted to a stream accepted by B&o? I would say the latter. RAAT (Roon Advanced Audio Transport) is Roon's own streaming protocol, which enables you to play Roon music to any Roon Ready hardware device or to devices connected to a Roon Bridge. Roon Bridge is a software package that extends Roon's audio playback capabilities i.e. RAAT to other devices or computers, including embedded platforms like the Raspberry Pi. The latter I have done (could have used a one-box solution like a bluesound node as well), thus the BS2 connected to the Roon Bridge is capable of playing RAAT.
Carolpa:[ Ulrike:You can just use roon bridge for any device: https://help.roonlabs.com/portal/en/kb/articles/roonbridgeInteresting. But do you technical speaking enjoying RAAT or is RAAT converted to a stream accepted by B&o? I would say the latter.
https://help.roonlabs.com/portal/en/kb/articles/roonbridge
A parallel example: B&o can not play DSF music files. So I have software in my music servers which makes it available to play on B&o. To follow your analogy B&o can play DSF, but B&o simply can't. The software converts it to a B&o eatable file.
But for some reason, the answer had to be moderated.
@Moderators: could you make a post which explains what triggers "moderation". I can imaging using specific words do, but sometimes it seems at random.
I haven't played around with the Library Settings myself, others may have.
My artist view is pretty clean - yes something like Prince appears 3 times (Prince, Prince and the Revolution, `and Prince & the NPG), of thats what you ar referring to. There are a bunch of settings as I say, or search the Roon Community for help.
Anyway my library looks clean enough, if I select Artist. It doesn't look as if its cluttered with artists who make the odd appearance on an album.
Under Artists, I usually then click one of the other filters (Focus, Favourites), so its pretty quick to get tp what I want.
Focus is about to become a good deal more powerful in the update coming this week.